The United States stock market, recognized as the largest public equity market globally, is currently navigating through a significant transformation that has captured the attention of investors, analysts, and financial institutions alikeA striking phenomenon is occurring: an increasing volume of trading activities is migrating from public exchanges to over-the-counter (OTC) platformsAccording to data from Bloomberg, projections suggest that by January 2025, a staggering 51.8% of stock trading volume in the United States will take place off-exchange, marking the first time that more than half of transactions occur outside traditional trading venuesThis unprecedented shift signifies not only a historical high but also a trend persisting for five consecutive months, with the OTC trading volume consistently surpassing 50% for three consecutive months.

The growth of OTC trading appears to be predominantly rooted within large financial institutions or what are recognized as "dark pools"—alternative trading venues that obscure the identity of buyers and sellers

Advertisements

Anna Cioatis Kuzlock, the head of market structure at Jefferies, delivered insights in a recent report, suggesting that this transition from open exchanges to OTC trading is evolving into a long-term trend, with the potential to become a permanent fixture in the market landscape.

This surge in OTC trading hasn't emerged overnight; rather, it has been a critical component of Wall Street's operations for yearsHistorically, public markets—like the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and the Nasdaq—have dominated, serving as the principal reference point for stock prices for most investorsThe ongoing change in this dynamic poses vital implications for market price mechanisms, which have traditionally relied on public auction venues for transparent valuation.

As reported by Larry Tab, head of market structure research at Bloomberg Intelligence, this shift indicates a continuation of a trend that has been observable for years

Advertisements

If this trajectory persists, it could have profound implications for the functionality of financial marketsHe pointed out that, theoretically, a rise in OTC transactions could lead to fewer competitive orders vying for the best prices in public markets, which may diminish the pricing efficiency between on-exchange and off-exchange trades.

In response to this rising trend, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has been taking proactive measures in recent years, implementing a series of reforms aimed at restructuring the market dynamics to attract more trading activities back to public exchangesThe SEC recognizes the necessity of a healthy public market for the stability of the entire financial ecosystem and the fiscal interest of investorsA considerable increase in non-public market transactions might exacerbate information asymmetry, making it difficult for investors to acquire comprehensive and accurate market information, thereby impacting fairness and resource allocation efficiency in trading.

Consequently, the SEC has proposed several reform measures designed to optimize market structure from various angles

Advertisements

However, the journey toward reform has not been straightforwardOut of the four reform proposals put forth by the SEC, numerous challenges emerged during discussions, consultations, and the negotiations of differing interestsAfter extensive deliberation, only two proposals successfully passed; these revolved around adjustments in stock pricing mechanisms and the execution methods of on-exchange versus off-exchange tradesThe alterations in stock pricing are intended to facilitate a more rational price formation process that accurately reflects market supply and demand alongside the true value of assetsMeanwhile, the adjustments to execution methods aim to enhance transaction transparency and efficiency while reducing costs to safeguard investors' legal rightsWhile merely a portion of the proposals succeeded, these developments stand as crucial strides in the SEC’s journey toward iterative reforms in market structure, laying a foundational stone for the normative progression of future financial markets.

Despite these substantial shifts, the threats to market efficiency remain relatively modest at this time

• Yen Poised for Surge
• A-Share Market Confidence Boosted
• Historic Milestone in U.S. Stock Market
• Fed's Rate Hike: A Jolt to the Markets
• Short-term Growing Pains in the Semiconductor Industry

As of January, 48.2% of all transactions were still executed through public exchanges, indicating that traditional venues remain integral to market operations.

Kuzlock from Jefferies highlighted that the increased OTC trading is closely linked to the rising volume of trades in stocks priced below one dollarThese lower-priced stocks are typically targeted by retail investors and predominantly handled internally by major market makers such as Citadel Securities and Virtu Financial.

When considering only stocks above the one-dollar threshold, Jefferies estimates that OTC trading accounts for less than 40% of the volumeIn light of this consideration, Kuzlock maintains that the shift from public markets to OTC platforms “does not necessarily mean that stock trading conditions will deteriorate in the future.”

Simultaneously, there has been a surge in the number of alternative trading systems (ATS) that provide alternative, anonymous trading mechanisms

These systems utilize diverse methods to pair buyers and sellers, dispensing with the necessity to disclose intended prices in public exchanges or auctions, thereby assisting institutional investors in mitigating the risk of information leakage that could influence pricing.

Bloomberg Intelligence analysis connects this evolving landscape with notable quantifiable growth; in November, the average daily trading volume on ATS hit approximately 1.7 billion shares, the highest level since March 2020, which reflects a 36% year-over-year increase.

Joe Saluzzi, co-founder of Themis Trading, remarked on the distinctive nature of this new trading dynamicHe pointed out that large institutional investors appear to garner a superior trading experience and increased value through these alternative methodsThis evolution in the structure of trading exemplifies a profound shift in how transactions occur in today's market, as financial entities increasingly leverage technology to optimize their trading strategies and mitigate risks.